FoodPlacee Passport United States · Pennsylvania · 80517
Verified Jimmy's Ice Cream
Cresco, Pennsylvania, USA
Rating★ 4.1 / 5
CategoryIce Cream Shop
Food Place Passport
Jimmy's Ice Cream in Pennsylvania
Enjoy delicious ice cream at Jimmy's Ice Cream, Cresco, PA. Find location, reviews, popular menu items like Banana Split, and best visiting times.
916 PA-390, Cresco, PA 18326, United States
Overview
About This Food Place
Located at 916 PA-390 in Cresco, PA, Jimmy's Ice Cream is a beloved ice cream shop known for its generous servings and wide range of classic flavors. Offering both hard ice cream and soft serve varieties, this spot delights visitors with treats like sundaes, banana splits, and creamy milkshakes.
The atmosphere is friendly and casual, perfect for cooling off on a warm summer day or grabbing a sweet dessert after nearby outdoor adventures. While payment is by cash only, the reasonable prices and quality portions make it a popular stop among locals and travelers alike.
Gallery
Photos from Jimmy's Ice Cream
Real shots of the food, atmosphere, and signature dishes at this location.
Local favorites
Why People Come Here
Known for generous portions and reasonable prices, this local ice cream shop offers a variety of hard and soft serve options perfect for a sweet treat in Cresco.
Variety of Ice Creams
From hard scoops to soft serve, including unique options like artic swirls blended with popular toppings such as Oreos and Reese’s cups.
Convenient Location
Situated at 916 PA-390 in Cresco, easy to find and a perfect stop after outdoor adventures or a day out.
Positive Local Reviews
Customers praise the delicious ice cream, large portions, and friendly service, making it a trusted spot for dessert.
Popular Banana Split
The Banana Split is a standout dish, favored by many visitors seeking a classic, indulgent ice cream experience.
Cash Only
Visitors should be prepared as this shop accepts cash only, adding a touch of old-fashioned charm to the experience.
Experience
When & How to Enjoy This Place
Jimmy's Ice Cream shines as a perfect sweet stop during outdoor activities or a relaxing day out in Cresco. Its hearty portions and variety of options invite leisurely visits and shared indulgences.
A great spot to satisfy ice cream cravings after a day spent exploring the local trails or as a refreshing treat under the summer sun. Be sure to bring cash to keep the enjoyable experience smooth. — FoodPlacee editorial note
Family-Friendly Outing
Enjoy a classic banana split or a soft serve Arctic swirl with the kids in a casual, welcoming setting.
Roadside Refreshment
Stop by for a quick, satisfying ice cream break while exploring the scenic drives and outdoor adventures near Cresco.
Sweet Reward
Treat yourself to a generous sundae or a creamy shake after a long day of hiking or zipline sessions nearby.
Takeout Treats
Order a variety of cones, sundaes, or shakes to enjoy at a local park or picnic area.
Casual Date Spot
Share a banana split or sample different ice cream flavors while strolling through Cresco on a warm evening.
Summer Treat Family-Friendly Sweet Desserts Popular Choice Takeout Roadside Stop Casual Evenings
Guest sentiment
What People Feel
A snapshot of what local diners frequently mention about this location.
A
Annie 2 week ago
"Great "hard ice cream" sundae! Milkshakes were cheap but not too good so I would skip it if I were you."
JE
John Emanuel 3 week ago
"Excellent soft serve ice cream! I highly recommend getting a sundae or cup! Just keep in mind they are CASH ONLY!"
MS
Mrunal Saraiya 1 month ago
"Excellent ice-cream after a 4 hour zipline adventure"
AR
Amanda Reiser 1 month ago
"Nice local ice cream shop. Perfect stop on a hot summers day. Plenty of hard ice cream choices, water ice (Italian ice) as well as soft serve with the ability to make shakes, sundaes, and artic swirls (soft serve with a blended in topping like Oreos, Snickers, or Reese's cups). There are generous servings especially with the artic swirls and shakes. Just note that this ice cream place is cash only, no credit cards accepted! However, the Mountain home diner right next door is a great place to grab a meal and they take card."
JM
J. Mortola 2 month ago
"Love this spot... nice variety, young man at the register is also the server and is as accomodating as can be... soft serve, hard ice cream, cones, sundaes, banana split ,shakes... you name it"
TF
Theresa Frangos 3 month ago
"Tasty, friendly, quick, reasonably priced. A great little spot for ice cream."
JD
Jonathan Dimmick 3 month ago
"Great off the beaten path pace for I've cream and cheap, altho if I had anything bad to say it would be that they don't have very many flavors altho the mountain home diner is next door so you can have dinner then ice cream for desert"
RP
Ryan Patenaude 4 month ago
"No longer owned by Jimmy. Ice cream was delicious, portions were large, prices were reasonable. Nothing fancy. We had 4 mediums in waffle cones."
Visit info
When to Visit
Weekly hours below — always confirm with the business before holidays or special events.
Today Updating...
Best time to visit
Ideally visited on warm, sunny days, this is a perfect spot to cool down while enjoying generous servings of ice cream.
Summer afternoons Early evenings for a relaxed treat Weekdays for lighter crowds Not suited for late-night visits (cash only may limit options)
On the map
Where This Food Place Lives
Find your way to Jimmy's Ice Cream in Pennsylvania .
Address 916 PA-390, Cresco, PA 18326, United States
Phone +1 570-595-2523
Area Pennsylvania
Call Address copied ✓
Questions answered
Food Place Questions
Find answers to common questions about Jimmy's Ice Cream to enhance your visit. These FAQs cover location, menu highlights, and customer tips.
Jimmy's Ice Cream is located at 916 PA-390, Cresco, PA 18326, United States. It’s a convenient stop for a refreshing treat in the Cresco area.
The Banana Split is a standout favorite. The shop offers a variety of hard and soft serve ice creams, sundaes, shakes, and artic swirls with blended toppings like Oreos and Reese’s cups.
Yes, this location accepts cash only. Credit cards are not accepted, so bringing cash is recommended to avoid any inconvenience.
Portions are generally generous, especially for shakes and artic swirls, with reasonable pricing. Some customers have noted occasional smaller cones, so portions may vary.
The shop features both hard and soft serve ice cream, water ice (Italian ice), as well as shakes and sundaes. Artic swirls are a unique option, blending soft serve with mix-ins like Snickers or Oreos.
With a solid rating of 4.1 based on 51 reviews, Jimmy's Ice Cream is well-regarded for taste, selection, and friendly service, though some note limited flavor variety.
Absolutely. Customers have recommended it as a perfect treat after outdoor adventures, such as ziplining, providing a refreshing and satisfying break.
Nearby brands
Related food places near Jimmy's Ice Cream
Other casual restaurants and brands diners often visit in Pennsylvania.
For owners
Own or manage this food place?
Update this page with accurate hours, menu details, photos, and business notes — and reach food lovers searching for places like yours on FoodPlacee.
Menus, prices, hours, services, and availability may change. Please contact the food place directly before visiting or ordering.